How to find the best hotel deal in Fire Island
Want to find hotel deals as easily as you book flights? Our clever search engine can do it all. Here's how you can save time and money when searching for your Fire Island hotel.
The earlier you book, the better. You're more likely to find a cheaper rate on a Fire Island hotel and have a greater range of choice when you plan in advance.
Still, be prepared to grab any last-minute offers. Some places drop their rates right before arrival to fill empty rooms. This is more likely to happen during low season or on quieter days, though.
Another secret to finding cheaper hotels? Stay flexible. If your plans aren't locked in, check rates across different dates and discover just how much you can save.
Avoid the risk of extra fees by searching for stays with free cancellation. If your plans fall through or you spot a better offer, you can cancel or modify your booking without penalty.
Where to stay in Fire Island
Central Fire Island
Central Fire Island is where your itinerary writes itself. If sightseeing is at the top of your to-do list, stay at any of these hotels and be moments from some standout attractions.
The Palms Hotel Fire Island sets you up to explore with ease. Around 3 kilometres away, it's a sought-after stay near Fair Harbour.
Atlantique Park on your agenda? Clegg's Hotel gets high marks for comfort and location. This hotel in Fire Island is about 2 kilometres away.
When to go to Fire Island
The weather often decides when it's best to go. If you prefer warmer conditions, July tends to deliver with a maximum high temperature of 29ºC (84ºF).
January is the coolest time of year, with lows of -4ºC (25ºF).
To enjoy mostly clear skies, search for Fire Island hotels during September. With an average of six days of rain, this is the driest month.
The wettest time of year is January. Go then and you'll likely get around eight days of rainfall.
Best hotels in Fire Island
Best budget hotels
Just need a place to sleep? Budget Fire Island hotels provide the basics so you can spend on what truly counts: adventures and filling your suitcase with souvenirs. Often equipped with money-saving amenities like laundry facilities and kitchenettes, you'll find at least six of these affordable stays across the city.
Courtyard Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex serves up comfort without the cost. Make use of a laundry, accessible parking and more at this 3-star option.
Travelodge by Wyndham Bay Shore Long Island offers 2-star value. Conveniences including a lift and Wi-Fi are there to make your Fire Island hotel stay easier.
Best hotels with a pool
Pool hotels in Fire Island come in various shapes and sizes. City hotels tend to feature rooftop or indoor pools, while resorts generally go big with numerous swimming areas and more room to lounge. Whether you're here for rest or play, there's a stay made for you.
Enjoy lazy days by the water at Residence Inn by Marriott Long Island Islip/Courthouse Complex. Along with an indoor swimming pool, this Fire Island hotel comes with a tennis court and a barbeque.
Best pet-friendly hotels
With around four pet-friendly Fire Island hotels, your best buddy can come along for the ride. Many have nearby parks or outdoor spaces to get some exercise, and some even offer extras like pet-friendly menus or grooming services. A few rules might apply, but most places go out of their way to make your furry friend feel welcome.
At Grove Hotel, thoughtful pet perks are part of the package. Air conditioning and Wi-Fi are other conveniences you'll find at this hotel in Fire Island.
The Palms Hotel Fire Island is another place that'll make your little travel buddy feel extra special. This popular accommodation option comes with a cafe and a 24-hour front desk.
