Hotels in West Tisbury

Find the best West Tisbury hotel for your dates, by price or preference

Compare hotel deals across hundreds of providers, all in one place

Look out for West Tisbury hotels with free cancellation or excellent ratings

Trusted West Tisbury hotel providers

See all hotels in West Tisbury

View more hotels
Prices may change – pop in your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveller searches and partner prices.
Prices may change – pop in your dates for the best estimate. Note that prices are based on previous traveller searches and partner prices.
View more hotels

Hotels in West Tisbury rated best by other travellers

Rated by travellers as the best in the city, these stays are all full marks for cleanliness, customer service and location.
See more

Fast facts

Sleep easy, armed with the stuff that's good to know before you go.
Highest rated hotelHI Martha's Vineyard Hostel – 4.4

How to find the best hotel deals in West Tisbury

Want to use the same magic that powers our award-winning flight search to find the best room rates on the internet? Here are a few tips to help you search and save in seconds.

How to find the best hotel deal in West Tisbury

  • You already use our search engine to find the best flight deals. Now you can use the same magic to uncover incredible offers on West Tisbury hotels. Save on your next stay with these tips.

  • Plan your stay ahead of time to save on your West Tisbury hotel. You'll also have a fuller lineup of stays and room types to choose from, particularly during high-demand times.

  • Still, act fast if you spot any last-minute offers. Some places reduce their rates right before arrival to fill rooms. This is more likely to happen during low season or on quieter days, however.

  • Another travel tip for cheaper hotels? Stay flexible. If your plans aren't locked in, check prices across different dates and discover how much you can save.

  • Search for stays with free cancellation. Lock in a deal today and easily cancel later if your plans change.

Where to stay in West Tisbury

Central West Tisbury

  • Choose the city centre and you'll never be far from your next adventure. Take your pick of these accommodation options that keep you close to the must-see attractions in central West Tisbury.

  • When it comes to accommodation options near Sea Witch Sailing Charters, Lambert's Cove Inn & Resort gets bonus points for being both comfy and convenient. Make yourself at home at this West Tisbury hotel and you'll be roughly 5 kilometres away.

  • Or experience the city from one of the hotels near Hiking trail. West Tisbury Inn is 3 kilometres or so from this top sight.

When to go to West Tisbury

  • The weather forecast can help shape your travel plans. August offers the warmest conditions, with maximum temperatures of 24ºC (75ºF).

  • February is the coolest month, with lows of -7ºC (19ºF).

  • Don't want to pack a raincoat? Search for West Tisbury hotels in September. This is the driest time to visit, with six days of rain on average.

  • The wettest time of year is February. Travel then and you'll likely get around eight days of rainfall.

Best hotels in West Tisbury

Best budget hotels

  • Keep your travel spend in check by choosing from at least ten budget West Tisbury hotels. Ideal for when you want to spend less on check-in and more on checking things out, these stays come with essentials like Wi-Fi, toiletries, and simple breakfast options.

  • Lambert's Cove Inn & Resort serves up comfort without the cost. Make use of parking, air conditioning and more at this 3-star accommodation option.

  • The Lightkeeper’s Inn offers conveniences such as air conditioning and Wi-Fi. Set yourself up at this 3-star West Tisbury hotel and make the most of your trip for less.

  • You'll also be happy with the prices at The Edgartown Inn, The Edgartown Collection, which is rated 3 stars. It features Wi-Fi and internet access.

Best hotels in West Tisbury for families

  • Heading away with the kids? You need a hotel that goes beyond a bed. Childcare services, activity centres, connecting rooms, and kids' menus make family stays easier. You'll find roughly eight family-friendly hotels in West Tisbury ready to welcome your crew.

  • Bring luxury to your family escape at Hob Knob. Rated 4 stars, this West Tisbury hotel features internet access and minigolf.

Best hotels with a spa

  • Swap sightseeing for some serious downtime at a West Tisbury hotel with a spa. With roughly three to choose from, they're designed for relaxation. Many offer features like saunas, hot tubs, beauty treatments, and hydrotherapy pools.

  • Escape to Mansion House Inn and Spa and focus on nothing but you. Bathrobes, a lobby bar and other thoughtful extras await you at this 3-star accommodation option.

Best hotels with a pool

  • A pool brings a new layer of fun to your trip. Book a resort and you'll likely find multiple swimming areas and maybe even water slides for kids. At city hotels, indoor and rooftop pools are the norm. Choose from at least four pool hotels in West Tisbury and dive right in.

  • Lambert's Cove Inn & Resort comes with an outdoor swimming pool, bicycle rentals and a garden. Get in a swim or simply kick back by the water at this West Tisbury hotel.

  • Good times are guaranteed at Harbour View Hotel. This popular option features an outdoor swimming pool, luggage storage and a fitness centre.

  • Alternatively, find time for fun at Island Inn. An outdoor swimming pool, this hotel has room service and air conditioning.

Finding cheap hotels in West Tisbury: FAQs

You can always cancel or amend your hotel reservation if you need to, but look out for hotels in West Tisbury with free cancellation or flexible booking options if you want to protect your money. Some hotels allow you to cancel and get your money back if your plans change.

Of course - the cheapest hotel deal we found within the next seven days is 136 € per night. If you need somewhere in the next 24 hours, we've found you somewhere to stay for 153 € per night.

The average price of a hotel during the week is 171 € per night, and the average price on weekends is 202 €. Overall, it looks like the cheapest day to stay in West Tisbury could be Monday.

We crunched some numbers on our calendar and found that Monday is the cheapest day to stay in West Tisbury. And the most expensive day seems to be Saturday

The cheapest month to stay in a hotel in West Tisbury is September, with an average price of 165 € per night. The most expensive month is January, when the average room rate can rise to 1.304 € per night. These average prices are based on all the hotels we found – from hostels through to fancy 5-star hotels.

The average price of a hotel in June is 219 € per night, which is around 21% lower than the rest of the year.
If you're hitting up West Tisbury with kids in tow, try HI Martha's Vineyard Hostel.